Jackson Hole, Wyoming.
Skiing in Winter and Fly Fishing in Summer, there are several perks to the role of central banker. This week the bankers were in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, fishing for answers to the employment - inflation conundrum. The occasion - the Federal Reserve, Kansas City, Economic Symposium, Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Why Wyoming? You may well ask?

In 1982 the conference moved to Jackson Hole (Kansas City district) to persuade Paul Volcker, then chairman of the Fed and an avid fly-fisherman, to attend. Flies and fish were the big lure for the head of the Fed - and so it began.

The location, based some 2,000 miles from New York and 5,000 miles from London is not ideal. Communication - in the early days - not always ideal either. Want a copy of the New York Times? The local store stocked today’s and yesterday’s but if you wanted today’s copy, you had to come back tomorrow - delivery lagged a day behind.

Monetary Policy and the Muddler Minnow* …
This year the theme was Labor Market Dynamics and Monetary Policy. Mario Draghi reassured markets there would be no early rise in rates in Europe! Quelle Surprise! Janet Yellen delivered a lecture on structural, cyclical, secular and frictional unemployment before claiming the mantle of Truman’s two handed economist to explain the Fed’s stance on future monetary policy.

On the one hand …
“If progress in the labor market continues to be more rapid than anticipated or if inflation moves up more rapidly than anticipated, resulting in faster convergence toward our dual objectives, then increases in the federal funds rate target could come sooner than the Committee currently expects and could be more rapid thereafter.”

On the other hand …
“If economic performance turns out to be disappointing and progress toward our goals proceeds more slowly than we expect, then the future path of interest rates likely would be more accommodative than we currently anticipate.”

Excellent. Yellen then left the room, thrust on a pair of waders, tied on a muddler minnow before making an excellent double spey cast into the River Snake. [*The muddler minnow is currently one of the most favoured trout flies amongst central bankers.]

The MPC Minutes … muddying the waters …
Back in the UK, the Bank of England released the minutes of the August MPC meeting. Two members of the committee, Martin Weale and Ian McCafferty  voted for an increase in base rates by 25 basis points. The Carney consensus has cracked. Charm school is out for the Summer. Markets fell, Sterling rallied, on the prospect of an early rate rise.

Inflation Update ... 
The day before, the ONS released the inflation figures for July. CPI fell to 1.6% from 1.9% prior month. Markets had rallied, Sterling fell, prospects of an imminent rate rise postponed. No one seemed to notice that service sector inflation was unchanged at 2.5%. The overall drop in the headline rate - attributable to goods inflation down to 0.8% from 1.4% in June. So why the drop in goods inflation?

Manufacturing output prices were flat but input costs fell by over 7% in the month. Effects of sluggish world trade, weak commodity and energy prices were exacerbated by the translation impact of a stronger Sterling.

Government Borrowing …
Thursday and the ONS released figures on government borrowing for the month of July. Four months into the year and borrowing remains off track compared to last year and to plan. In the first four months, total borrowing was £37.0 billion compared to £35.2  billion in 2013. In July borrowing was down to £0.7 billion from £1.6 billion last year. An improvement but with an economy expanding by over 3% in the first half of the year, we would expect a big improvement in borrowing given the strength of the recovery.

Government spending is not the problem, nor VAT receipts up by 5%. The problem is revenues from income and capital gains tax are actually down on prior year over the first four months of the fiscal year. In part this is a result of strong receipts in the first quarter last year which may level out in due course. Compared to two years ago, revenues are up 5%. Even so, for the year as a whole the Chancellor will still have some work to do if the OBR target is to be met.

Retail Sales …
Retail sales in July were up by 2.6% after growth of 4% in the first half of the year. A disappointment, perhaps. Internet sales were up by 11% accounting for 11% of all retail activity. It will take more than a few digital mannequins to reverse fortunes on the high street but it is a tad to soon to make the call about a slow down in overall activity. The house market remains strong in terms of prices and the Council of Mortgage Lenders reported a 15% increase in gross mortgage leading last month.

So what of base rates …
The MPC minutes suggested the rate rise could come earlier than expected but news on inflation and retail sales suggest the rates will be kept on hold until 2015. No rate rise in prospect in Europe but Janet Yellen has “nowcast” a muddler minnow into the thought stream. A rate rise in the USA on the cards for Q2 next year or even earlier? Possibly. In the UK - February or June would appear to be the call.

So what happened to sterling this week?
Sterling closed down against the dollar at $1.657 from $1.669 but up against the Euro at 1.252 from 1.246. The Euro was down against the dollar at 1.324 (1.246).

Oil Price Brent Crude closed down at $102.32 from 102.96. The average price in August last year was $111.28.

Markets, rallied on the fishing report from Wyoming. The Dow closed up at 17,031 from 16,637 and the FTSE closed up at 6,775 from 6,685.

UK Ten year gilt yields were unchanged at 2.41 and US Treasury yields closed at 2.342 from 2.39. Gold was largely unchanged at $1,302.

That’s all for this week. Join the mailing list for The Saturday Economist or forward to a friend.

John
© 2014 The Saturday Economist by John Ashcroft and Company. Economics, Corporate Strategy and Social Media ... Experience worth sharing.

The material is based upon information which we consider to be reliable but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. We accept no liability for errors, or omissions of opinion or fact. In particular, no reliance should be placed on the comments on trends in financial markets. The receipt of this email should not be construed as the giving of investment advice.

UK Interest Rates on hold ...
No surprise this week as the MPC voted to keep rates on hold and to maintain the asset purchase facility at £375 billion. The decision to increase rates may becoming more finely balanced for some but the news from around the world, will disturb the hawks and give succour to the doves. The rate rise may well be held over into the new year, despite the continued strong performance of the domestic economy. The minutes of the MPC meeting, due later this month, may provide some insight into the overall views of the individual committee members.

ECB and Rates ... problems in the East
In Europe, rates were kept on hold as Draghi continues to consider QE. Action is needed but the futile process of debt monetisation will do little to offset the economies beset by weak levels of domestic demand. Complaints against the need for labour reform and excessive regulation will largely miss the point.

Italy is slipping back into recession with forecasts for the current year downgraded once again to growth of just 0.2%. France will struggle to hit the 1% growth target this year and German export performance is slowing as economies are transfixed by the crisis in Ukraine. Trade sanctions and threat of war are damaging exports from Euro land to Eastern Europe and to Russia. The Euro trading block is now imperilled by it’s very “raison d’être” at inception. Growth in the Euro economies is expected to be just 1% this year with no prospect of a rate rise on the horizon until late 2015 / 2016 at the earliest.

Production and Manufacturing ...
In the UK, manufacturing data was surprisingly weak in the latest data for June but Euroland is not to blame. Output increased in the month by just 1.9% after strong growth of 3.6% in the first quarter and 4% in April and May. In the second quarter overall growth was up by 3.2%. The underlying data from the Markit/CIPS Manufacturing PMI® suggests strong growth continued into June and July which suggests the latest ONS data may be something of an aberration.

[We are adjusting our forecast for the year to growth in manufacturing of 3.4% based on the latest data. Expectations for UK GDP growth are unchanged at 3% following revisions to our service sector forecast.]

The Car Market …
The SMMT reported strong car sales in July, with new registrations up by 6% in the month and 10% in the year to date. Output increased by 3.5% over the year. The car market is on track to sell 2.45 million units this year. That’s actually higher than the levels achieved in 2007. Assuming output hits the 1.55 million mark, the deficit (trade in cars) will increase to almost 900,000 units.

Car manufacturing is benefitting from the recovery in consumer confidence and household spending but the trade deficit will increase as a result of the strength of domestic demand and limitations to domestic capacity. The UK cannot enjoy a period as the strongest growth economy in the Western world without a significant deterioration in the trade balance.

Deficit trade in goods and services … 
And so it continued to prove with the latest trade data. The deficit trade in goods increased slightly in the month of June to £9.5 billion offset by a £7 billion surplus in services. For the second quarter, the deficit was £27.4 billion (trade in goods) and just under £7 billion overall, goods and services. The service sector surplus was  £20.5 billion.

For the year as a whole, we expect the goods deficit to be £112.3 billion offset by an £80 billion plus serve sector surplus. No threat to the recovery but we still have concerns about the current account deterioration and the drop in overseas investment income.

In the first six months of the year, exports of goods have fallen by almost 8% in value and imports have fallen by 4.6%. World trade growth has been subdued in the first six months of the year yet UK domestic demand increased by 3%. Sterling appreciation against the dollar has lead to a translation impact on the trade balance rather than an elasticity effect.  

Construction and housing ...
The latest adjustment for construction data confirms the recovery continues driven by a huge increase in new housing. Total output increased by 5.3% in June, up by 4.8% in Q2 2014 compared to Q2 last year. The total value of new work in the month increased by 5.8% with the volume of new housing increasing by 18% compared to June last year.

House Prices ...
The increase in housing supply is doing little to assuage the demand for house moves and house prices. Halifax and Nationwide reported prices up by 10% in July. Our transaction model is simple. Activity is a function of house prices and the real cost of borrowing. With mortgages fixed at 4%, the double digit capital appreciation is irresistible to the basic mechanics of a free market. The real cost of borrowing is negative 6%. Demand for housing will continue to out strip supply, despite the regulatory adjustments to the mortgage market.

So what happened to sterling this week?
Sterling closed down against the dollar at $1.6774 from $1.682 and unchanged against the Euro at 1.252. The Euro was largely unchanged against the dollar at 1.341.

Oil Price Brent Crude closed up slightly at $105.02 from 104.84. The average price in August last year was $111.28.

Markets, closed mixed. The Dow closed up 61 points at 16,554 from 16,493 and the FTSE closed down 112 points at 6,567 from 6,679.

UK Ten year gilt yields were down at 2.46 from 2.557and US Treasury yields closed at 2.42 from 2.49. Gold was up at $1,305 from $1,293.

That’s all for this week. Join the mailing list for The Saturday Economist or forward to a friend.

John
© 2014 The Saturday Economist by John Ashcroft and Company. Experience worth sharing.

The material is based upon information which we consider to be reliable but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. We accept no liability for errors, or omissions of opinion or fact. In particular, no reliance should be placed on the comments on trends in financial markets. The receipt of this email should not be construed as the giving of investment advice.

UK …
This week, the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee voted to maintain Bank Rate at 0.5%.  The Committee also voted to maintain the stock of QE assets at £375 billion. No real surprise, UK rates are expected to remain on hold until the second quarter of 2015. For the moment, UK policy is relatively clear cut.

USA …
Over in the USA, matters became a little more diffuse. Tapering is expected to continue, concluding the asset purchase programme in September or October this year. But then what happens next? In March, Janet Yellen head of the Fed, gave a clear indication US rates would begin to rise within six months of the end of tapering. Markets reacted badly and the FOMC was minded to recant.

This week, testifying before the Joint Economic Committee of the U.S. Congress, Chairman Kevin Brady pushed pushed Yellen for more clarity on when the FOMC would raise interest rates. The Fed chair would not be drawn on this occasion. “There is no mechanical formula for when that would occur” - the somewhat mechanical and evasive response. Oh yes, a month is a long time in the formulation of monetary policy.

Europe …
In Europe, Mario Draghi, President of the ECB, faced the opposite dilemma. With modest growth forecast for Euroland this year, inflation below target at less than 1% and a Euro strengthening against the dollar ($1.375), the Italian banker is under pressure to alleviate European  monetary conditions still further.

Playing for time, Draghi stated policy makers at the bank were comfortable with action in early June. Action awaits the “staff projections” for growth and inflation next month, before considering the next step. Draghi must hope forecasts are revised upwards. Having promised to “do what it takes” to stimulate growth, the President is clearly at a loss, as to what can be done next.

A reduction in base rates to the zero floor would have little economic impact. Experimentation with negative rates is a high risk strategy. The move would thrill academic economists but cause trauma in the markets. This is no time for experimentation with central bank novelties. QE is muted as a possibility but with German and French long rates at 1.45% and 1.9%, there seems little cause to push rates lower. Ten year bond rates in Spain and Italy are this week trading within 25 basis points of UK gilts.

MPC Dilemma …
So here in a way is the dilemma for the MPC. The UK economy is growing at 3% a year, unemployment is falling at such a rate, we may have to close the job centres in 2017. Inflation is below target but as Mario Draghi pointed out this week, it is the weakness in  international commodity prices, oil, energy and food, the real determinants of low inflation. Low inflationary pressure exacerbated or assisted by the rise in the Euro (and Sterling) against the Dollar.

The UK is caught in the Dollar Euro vortex, with basic economics pushing monetary policy in opposing directions apparently. The MPC cannot move ahead of the Fed or much in advance of Europe for that matter without pushing Sterling still higher.

Deflation the illusion - OECD World Forecasts
This month the OECD forecast a recovery in world growth this year to 3.4% in 2014 and almost 4% in 2015. The Euro area is set to grow by 1.2% and 1.7% over the period. Euro inflation is set to rise above 1.2% next year.

Commodity prices (base metals) are demonstrating a price basing action, Oil Brent Crude basis is trading ahead of last year. The international price profile can change quickly and dramatically. The threat of deflation - an illusion - which may quickly dissipate.

A strong ECB president should do nothing. The US must accept rates will rise within six months of the end of tapering. This would leave the MPC free to begin the inevitable rate rise in the second quarter of next year.

Want to here more, don’t miss the quarterly economics presentation on Wednesday at DWF next week. The multi media roadshow rolls on!

So what happened to sterling this week?
The pound closed unchanged against the dollar at $1.685 from $1.687 and up against the Euro at 1.224 (1.217). The dollar closed at 1.375 from 1.377 against the euro and at 101.18 (102.23) against the Yen.

Oil Price Brent Crude closed at $108.16 from $108.50. The average price in May last year was $102.3.

Markets, the Dow closed unchanged at 16,544 from 16,542 and the FTSE also closed up at 6,821 from 6,814. The markets are set to the move, the push before the rush.

UK Ten year gilt yields closed at 2.68 (2.72) and US Treasury yields closed at 2.62 from 2.72. Gold moved down $1,287 from $1,296.

That’s all for this week. Join the mailing list for The Saturday Economist or forward to a friend.

John

© 2014 The Saturday Economist by John Ashcroft and Company. Experience worth sharing.

The material is based upon information which we consider to be reliable but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. We accept no liability for errors, or omissions of opinion or fact. In particular, no reliance should be placed on the comments on trends in financial markets. The receipt of this email should not be construed as the giving of investment advice. It's just for fun, what's not to like! Dr John Ashcroft is The Saturday Economist.